Monday, December 12, 2011

Whitewash that's Hogwash. Nuclear Power, Safety, the WHO & the IAEA


For anyone who wants to know what Chernobyl and Fukushima mean, these documentaries have the lowdown and are very well done. The first is about 50 mins long, with subtitles and English commentary and the older of the two, told from an insider perspective:




We are still learning about the intense and sustained damage that radiation can do from the populations of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. A further long term study can be done on Chernobyl (1986) But those studies have been grossly underplayed.  It is not a pretty picture.

There is generally an expectation that organizations within the UN that deal with world health and the dangers of nuclear power will deal with these areas keeping human safety and health as their most important mandates. A huge question is why the WHO and the IAEA have proved to be nuclear industry advocates rather than safety and health advocates.

The WHO (World Health Organization (a part of the United Nations) claims now that it is not allowed to independently investigate the results of nuclear accidents, or anything nuclear for that matter, not even future effects without the permission of the IAEA.
- not the immediate health effects
- not the epidemiology (future health effects on populations).
- not anything!

This legally binding agreement with the IAEA (another part of the UN) has been in force since 1959! So, we can only conclude that the nuclear industry is very well protected by the IAEA.

The WHO actually reports to the Development Group while the IAEA directly reports to the UN Security Council!  In theory, both have equal weight, but in fact the IAEA holds absolute sway over the entire nuclear field including matters of worker and public health.

Just as Chernobyl's true extent and danger were minimized, for Fukushima too similar 'statements' have started circulating now,  e.g. "the epidemiology will take years to sort out" but then, all people in medicine know that that's hogwash.  You won't catch a single radiology technician anywhere near even an x-ray machine without a heavy lead suit and a dosimeter on the lapel! That's just for x-ray exposure, whereas nuclear energy releases gamma rays, thousands of times more damaging to life.

The radiation from a damaged nuclear plant spreads through the air, it seeps into the ground and then is spread by underground water and in the case of Fukushima, the radiation is getting right into the ocean. The radiation spreads through the food chain.

Radiation is silent, radiation is deadly, radiation effects can last unchanged for 30 years or more.  Radiation actually targets developing tissues; growing tissue; particularly children (the whole child), and for adults, at least the bone marrow, thyroid, reproductive cells, heart, skin etc.

The Chernobyl disaster is believed to have affected over 9 million people. Yet the IAEA claims only 31 direct deaths and maybe 2000 "avoidable thyroid cancers in irradiated children." They call this 'rigorous science' saying that health effects have to be validated in approved labs - of which there are only 2, one in France and one in Monaco - and all suitably far enough away from Chernobyl to completely defeat the purpose

Don't take it lightly. There is no such thing as 'safe' nuclear power!

A new NPP is to be commissioned shortly in Kudangulam in South India. At the final stages it's being held up by local protesters but the government is hard at work squelching the protests, paying off village leaders, appointing committees that will deliberate for the next 30 years, etc. - while the commissioning work goes on full swing but oh so quietly.

This NP project sits directly in the path of any powerful tsunami coming from the Indian ocean, and this area was in fact badly hit in the 2004 tsunami, yet our government and the promoters confidently state that all approvals and safety studies have been fully 'complied with'.

Look around you. There's probably a NPP project functioning or being built not too far away. Then look at the fallout maps for Chernobyl and Fukushima...

What was that Jesus once said about beautiful gravesites...?
The benevolent and protective IAEA's whitewash is increasingly being recognized as hogwash! You can't always fool everyone.


Short key to the main points in the video:
Nuclear Controversies by Vladimir Tchertkoff; Released in 2003, 51 minutes
Key Points
  • Intro – Children’s perspective
  • 2:30 – Agreement between IAEA and WHO – WHO cannot research health effects of radiation or effects of nuclear accidents if IAEA does not agree
  • 7:00 – Former head of WHO admits they answer to IAEA
  • 14:00 – Chernobyl had no effect -UN
  • 15:45 – Scientist refutes UN
  • 27:30 – 200km from Chernobyl, 10,000 becquerels measured inside child
  • 30:20 – According to Professor Yury Bandazhevsky (former director of the Medical Institute in Gomel), Over 50 Bq/kg of body weight lead to irreversible lesions in vital organs
  • 30:50 – *MUST SEE* Refutes internal radiation! -Norman Gentner, Secretary of UN UNSCEAR (United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation), ~2001 (See Gentner speak at 13:55 — No increase in leukemia, even among liquidators)
  • 34:15 – *MUST SEE* Internal or external it makes no difference!
  • 45:20 – Internal lesions
  • 49:25 – Now only 20 out of 100 considered healthy, before it was 80 out of 100
  • Keep your eye out for Chris Busby at 35:30 and 38:40

The second one is even more graphic, beautifully shot, and utterly horrifying:


 


(map courtesy of http://bit.ly/tD0pnw)

For more info see:
http://bit.ly/s0nioo THE OTHER REPORT ON CHERNOBYL (TORCH) 2006 on the 20th anniversary of the disaster.
&
http://bit.ly/uZjqdN  Avoidable Tragedy post-Chernobyl  A Critical Analysis

&

http://1.usa.gov/vItPlP  Congressman Markley's report: Dec. 9, 2011: New Report Details Conspiracy to Delay, Weaken US Nuclear Safety in Wake of Fukushima
“Regulatory Meltdown” Reveals Efforts to Improve Nuclear Safety Undermined ...

Incidentally, I just noticed that the original video embedded above had disappeared. This after more than 500 successful views and shares of this page! No conspiracy theories right now, but given that this has never happened to me before, and I do embed a lot of videos... In any case, I did find another feed, so it's up again. 
If you should view this post and not find the video loading Please Do let me know in the comments. 



Thursday, November 24, 2011

Silence! Let the Mimicry Begin...


While humans have great talent, as we saw in our last post, no human mimic is going to even come close to this.

Silly looking thing isn't it? That's just the front end though. The Lyrebird is absolutely the best. Watch, listen, and be amazed. David Attenborough is your commentator!

You can read more about the Superb Lyrebird Menura novaehollandiae and its smaller cousin here

After watching, and listening, you might get an idea of why the Australian Aborigines call them "Weringerong," "Woorail," and "Bulln-bulln" !


Friday, November 11, 2011

HAPPY FEET, BACH & MORE

There's some amazing talent in this world! I thought I'd share some that I recently ran into. The first link came from facebook (actually picked up by my son Rommel and shared on his timeline). That led to a bit of searching ... Here are two amazing renditions of Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D minor



You need to see both, so don't lose patience.




I wonder which rendering you preferred? Bach would have totally cracked up on whichever he had seen! Such talent, timing, precision, coordination and one can hardly imagine the hard work and endless practice that produces such perfection.


And to finish off, some jazz, and the linking beauty is that wonderful footwork!



And that bass line is with just her left foot! I wish here that the whole session had been taped, but one enjoys what one gets.

Barbara Dennerlein can be found at her home page here: http://www.barbaradennerlein.com/en/

In the first two I have no idea who the performers are. I wish the original sharers had thought to acknowledge the artistes. If anyone knows these young people, please do share that info with us by posting a comment here.


Tuesday, October 04, 2011

Snakes in the (Indian) Grass - The Big 4 - Dealing With Snakebites


A 'narcissistic' Indian Cobra
(Naja naja)
INDIA'S "BIG FOUR" VENOMOUS SNAKES



















The Russell's Viper
Echis carinatus - the Saw Scaled Viper
Notice how variable the colouring can be.


Saranya, my daughter, did recover from a severely venomous Echis snakebite. It's part of the 'normal' risk for snake rescuers. That bite was the original driving force to bringing all the available information together in one place. As my own snake rescue work has almost been non-existent (due to busyness) I haven't really kept myself very up-to-date on the developments in treating snakebites for the last couple of years . This article was originally written even before that and badly needed to be brought up to date.

Incidentally, it's so good to see that the next generation is showing an interest in preserving these wonderful, though somewhat dangerous creatures! But for those who do get bitten and given the popularity of this post and the hope that it has proved helpful to quite a few, I thought it was time to brush-up on snake bites.  I summarise here a synopsis of the latest (as of October 2012) steps to be taken when bitten by a snake...

The Common Krait
First and foremost, no snakebite should be ignored. Most bites may be from nonvenomous snakes and sometimes even venomous snakes do not deliver enough venom when biting to prove dangerous, but that is no excuse not to go to the nearest emergency room, get evaluated, and if necessary, have treatment started. Early treatment is the key to preventing complications, and to saving lives, limbs and kidneys!
In India, it is conservatively estimated that 20,000 to 50,000 people die annually from snakebites. Morbidity (i.e. nonfatal injury rather than mortality-death) is also significant. These are not small numbers, and there seems to have been little improvement in reducing the fatalities over the years in spite of now having good supplies of polyvalent antisnakevenom available in all population centers.

The major reason for the high mortality rate (about 10% to 15% of all those reporting bites) is the delay in getting the victim to treatment. All too often snakebite victims are sent great distances to 'big' hospitals and the delay in starting treatment is the direct cause of death.

Of course, one root cause for snake bites is that rampant human population growth has forced snakes and people to occupy the same space. In my experience many of the snakes one runs into in towns, cities and villages are nonvenomous. These commonly jnclude the rat snake, water snakes, wolf snakes, trinket snakes, blind snakes, and and tree snakes like the bronze back, cat, and the lovely green vine snake. These snakes will bite when cornered but the bites should certainly not result in any serious medical problem. Clean the bite site and apply a good antiseptic such as Betadine. That's if you know your snakes, saw the snake clearly and when you KNOW with absolute certainty (positive snake identification can be tricky) that the snake that bit you was harmless! The general rule (see below) with any snakebite is to take no chances and to immediately seek out professional medical help. Let the physician decide whether your bite was dangerous or not.

However, India's 'big four' are not uncommon either! Very surprisingly, about 80% of the venomous snakebites in India come from the small saw scaled viper (Echis carinatus), and though this is a little fellow, it can be deadly. This has to do more (I think) with the fact that the saw scaled is small and inconspicuous, has good ground-like camouflage colours, and because it thinks it is invisible, it does not move away when approached and often gets stepped on - resulting in a bite. All the other three will try to make a fast getaway when anything big approaches them.

Snakes do not bite unless provoked, so it's probably true that a lot of the fatalities that do occur are in fact preventable. If you find a snake in your house or garden please be calm, do not approach the snake or try to drive it away, and promptly call a snake rescuer. In other words, right now get out and identify the snake rescuers in your area, store their mobile numbers well ahead of time so that you can save yourself and the snake comfortably when the need arises.

Krait bites are variable and often show little obvious pain or swelling at the site of the bite, which can lead one to think that the bite was harmless - DON'T BE FOOLED - take no chances and treat every bite as potentially fatal.  Some bites might even be 'dry' with the venomous snake biting but not injecting any venom. At the same time some bites can seem to be harmless but may actually have a slow start to symptoms - often Krait and saw scaled or other viper bites can have this innocent-seeming start but then turn very ugly. Just because there is no obvious pain or swelling DO NOT assume that the bite was harmless. Treat every bite as potentially deadly till proved otherwise by the competent medical authority.

FIRST AID:
In the absence of a nearby doctor, those accompanying the bitten one need to first CALM the victim down and then immobilise the affected limb (if it is a limb). Not one of the Indian poisonous snakes brings INSTANT death. You do have time to get the victim to a hospital and treated, but do get moving immediately.
DON'Ts:
Applying any sort of chemicals or external medicines, home remedies, nature cures, and cutting into the site of the bite to suck out the venom (was the mainstay of first aid in my youthful heyday) have all fallen out of favour. As we remark in the comments, you can say your prayers and mantras as you move towards the hospital, but do not be foolhardy enough to think that your prayers or those of any holy man, will save you from a Big 4 bite!

DOs:
BE CALM ; GET MOVING TOWARDS A HOSPITAL ; CALL AHEAD FOR ANTIVENIN!

The use of pressure bandaging is controversial but if done with something like a crepe bandage AFTER starting to move towards the nearest competent hospital, and not wound on too tightly, perhaps combined with a simple splint or sling, may help to slow the spread of venom through the lymphatic system. The blood supply must NOT be cut off! On the whole, perhaps if the bitten one will be getting to a HOSPITAL within 3 or 4 hours, it may be better not to attempt any pressure bandaging, but advice on this point varies.
As you move the bitten one towards a hospital, try to gently remove any jewellery worn on the affected limb - like wrist watch, rings, bangles, bracelets, anklets, or metti (toe rings) as these may cause problems if there is subsequent swelling or edema associated with the bite. Also loosen constricting clothing like ties or belts.
Next, get the person to the nearest good hospital as fast as possible. Walking and running for the victim are to be avoided, as is movement of the affected limb. Try to carry the person at least on a pallet or makeshift stretcher if no vehicles are available.
Giving anything by mouth is best avoided except if dehydration is a risk, in which case consider sips of oral rehydration fluids (clean water mixed with a little salt and sugar will do OK).
Some venomous snakes have cardiotoxins (poisons that can slow or stop the heart) so if possible try to keep the affected limb BELOW the level of the heart.

The victim should be encouraged to:
Remain calm.
Move minimally.
Breathe deeply and evenly to bring the pulse rate to a slower steady state.

Particularly as you move towards the closest hospital, keep a watch on breathing and on keeping airways clear. If the person has difficulty breathing, first see that there is nothing blocking the airway (like the tongue, secretions, or vomit) and if necessary be prepared to help the person to breathe by doing chest compressions or mouth to mouth. Rarely will the heart be affected so early on, so full scale CPR may not be needed.
Those having cell phones should call ahead so that even if antivenom is not available, it will be made available by the time the patient arrives. remember that 10, or even more, vials of antivenom may be needed, so ask whoever is at the other end to ensure an adequate supply, OR in the absence of definite knowledge, just get the victim to the nearest hospital. In Tamil Nadu, all the government hospitals are expected to have stock of antivenom.
Observe the snakebite victim carefully while taking them to the hospital. Note the time of the bite and its location and try to get as much accurate information on the appearance and size of the snake. Any symptoms such as discolouration at the site or of the affected limb, swelling, signs of bruising, changes in eyes (e.g. droopy lids), eyesight, speech, breathing, sweating, unusual eye movements, dizziness, bruising, bleeding, lowered level of consciousness, loss of consciousness, or other difficulties should be noted.
If the snakebite victim happens to faint, the most important thing is to make sure that they are able to breathe. If possible lean the head backward and depress the tongue to keep the throat open. Do not waste time trying to make them recover from the faint. Make sure that they are breathing and concentrate on getting to the hospital fast. If, as you move towards the hospital, you do have access to a phone or mobile, ask the doctors who are waiting for you for advice particularly in case of fainting as sometimes this may indicate that a medical condition called "shock" is setting in and that is potentially more dangerous than even the effects of snake venom! It is important to keep the bite victim warm.
Try to get information on what snake it was, appearance, size, etc. but please don't waste time on this or on trying to catch the snake! Getting the person to a competent hospital is the only major priority!

TREATMENT:
Mostly, if there are symptoms, the doctors will immediately start the antivenom treatment (subq checking for allergies is considered a waste of valuable time; if there are allergies deal with them clinically) and then one will most profitably spend one's time praying that there will be no complications. In case of allergy to the antivenin or an immune reaction the doctors will temporarily stop the antivenin, treat those symptoms, but then should proceed with administering the antivenin. Physicians should be competent at handling anaphylactic shock! - please see the PPT at the end for more details...

On admission, and at relevant intervals afterwards, doctors will probably check on how well the blood is clotting (bleeding time, clotting time, and sometimes tests like PT and aPTT), kidney function (urine output, blood urea, creatinine and electrolyte levels), and of course the vital signs - pulse, breathing, temperature, blood pressure and the amount of oxygen in the blood (pO2). They may also keep tabs on the patient's haemoglobin, blood cell counts (especially platelets), ECG (EKG) and perhaps the blood gases too.
Ophiophagus hannah the King Cobra
Sometimes even after a day or two, things can go wrong with the patient starting bleeding, kidney failure, or even the heart could be affected, so keeping the victim under medical observation even after the antivenom has been administered is important. Most of the time, alert medical staff will successfully deal with each crisis as it arises.
I only eat snakes!

My daughter was bitten by the Saw Scaled Viper (Echis, see above), but sometimes a non-big-four candidate can cause trouble. In our our area of South India, especially in hilly areas, we do run into bites from the Hump-nosed pit viper (Hypnale hypnale) the King Cobra (bites are rare), the Bamboo pit viper, and the Malabar pit viper too.
Hump-nosed Pit Viper

The Malabar Pit Viper Trimeresurus malabaricus is again a very variable snake. It frequents the highlands of SW India, and has dark, light, green and brown morphs!













The Bamboo Pit Viper


Our recent Big 4 snake rescue were a Russel's viper and you can get the full story here: http://bartramia.blogspot.in/2013/01/rescue-that-snake.html#.UPmpl_JyErw
and a multiple snake rescue :

The Noble Indian Cobra!


There have been many hits on this article as well as requests for more information, so I thought I would share some of the resources that I found most helpful:

1.Snakebite Envenomation in India: A Rural Medical Emergency Indian Pediatrics 2006;43:553-554http://www.indianpediatrics.net/june2006/june-553-554.htm
2. Kraits deliver some powerful neurotoxins that cause few initial symptoms at the site of the bite but can be deadly within a couple of hours. Detailed Instructions for Krait bites can be found here:  http://www-surgery.ucsd.edu/ent/DAVIDSON/Snake/Bungarus.htm *Note that Indian polyvalent antivenom is effective against Krait venom also.
3. The University of Adelaide's toxinology resources website has an excellent database of information on most of the poisonous snakes in the world, first aid, treatment, and antivenins. Use the search engine to find the information you need: http://www.toxinology.com/fusebox.cfm?fuseaction=main.snakes.search
4. Snakebite Research Unit, Little Flower HospitalAngamaly, Kerala - First Aid
5.A helpful interview with Romulus Whittaker in The Hindu: http://www.hindu.com/mag/2004/06/13/stories/2004061300400200.htm
6. Guidelines for the Clinical Management of Snake bites in the South-East Asia Region http://203.90.70.117/PDS_DOCS/B0241.pdf By the WHO is now a bit dated (1999).
7. "Snake Bite in South Asia: A Review" in PLOS Neglected Tropical Diseases (Jan 2010) http://www.plosntds.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pntd.0000603
also here (same article) : http://ukpmc.ac.uk/articles/PMC2811174//reload=0;jsessionid=FBC1BE8828656BCE7CC2B211EA5EAB10
8. "Commissioned article: management of exotic snakebites"  Well worth reading even though it does not cover Indian snakes. 
http://qjmed.oxfordjournals.org/content/102/9/593.long 

IMPORTANT NOTE!!!
It is our instinctive reaction of fear, and the frenzy that follows it that leads to most of our snake 'problems'. In my experience, a snake, when it knows it's been spotted, will try to find some way to escape. If it is allowed to move out calmly, that is the end of that. 
Unfortunately, we don't want the snake to leave... we want to see it dead. All questions, such as whether it is venomous or not, are left to be discussed after the snake is well and truly dead!

Please leave the snakes alone, and if at all possible they will leave you alone too. What they are after are the rodents, frogs and insects that frequent our habitations. The poor snake only wants to do her hunting as quietly as possible and then disappear, so why not live and let live???

FOR MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS: HERE'S A GOOD PPT ON TREATING SNAKEBITE
Snakebite Management in India
View more presentations from Ashendu Pandey

http://bartramia.blogspot.com/2013/01/rescue-that-snake.html 






Digg!


Monday, October 03, 2011

SWADESHI Rediscovering India's Independence


India is in crisis. Inflation has raised its ugly head. Even our huge new middle class is in trouble. The poor may sink completely. Our greatest immediate difficulty is that those most essential of commodities - staple foods, vegetables, milk - are seeing the fastest rising rates. Potable water is sold at Rs 20 a litre and water is scarce.

At the same time, complexity takes hold of our economic, political, religious, and cultural fronts. Yet we are being sold a strange brew of oversimplifications. It's the cost of development, they say; or, reform is always painful and so costly to implement...

There is a deliberate bid to reduce the political fallout by confusing the issues. Great and somewhat relentless forces have silently been unleashed in our nation. Though we can see the evil clearly in our neighbours' experiences, we are blinded to our own inability to see ourselves as we really are.

Strategically and with global implications, the restoration of democracy in Pakistan, the sidelining of 'Mushy' Musharraf, and the now more hidden face of the military oligarchy there, coupled with the fallout of the 'war on terror' on Pakistan's border with Afghanistan, has led the US and the EU to seek much closer ties with India.

We see the rise of the West in India most clearly in the fields of defence and retail. More subtle signs include the red carpet welcome to Western based MNCs, as well as a deliberate (but silent) turning away from the independence theme of Swadeshi that formed the economic backbone of Mahatma Gandhi's freedom movement.

It is not just one Indian national party that has changed their tune to welcome the latest trend to global capitalistic hegemony. Both our leading political blocks - the Congress led UPA, and the BJP led NDA, are openly shedding nonalignment for Western goodies, while the communist block has incinerated itself and a successful new party is focussed on anticorruption but doesn't seem to have any vision for India.

Just a couple of small examples show how far we have come since our 'non-aligned' days of standing tall for freedom. On the one hand our politicians try to convince us that our economic and defence needs dictate our strengthening trade with the West and even with Israel. On the other hand, we are not willing to accept desperately needed gas from Iran. Iran's policy of seeking nuclear self-sufficiency (as we too had done) apparently now offends our Realpolitik and the necessity of pandering to the American foreign policy.

So much so that our traditional pro-Palestine stance has come a cropper and even while sitting in the UN Security Council, we follow the US line on what is and is not terror - even to the point of winking at genocides! Another traditional ally has been offering us gas at a rate that will make it the preferred fuel for the nation but we dare not take the offer as it will 'offend' the mighty neoglobalist Americans.

We feel safer as American dependents - now how strange is that?

I think the biggest blind spot that we have is our fear of China. There is no logic to this fear. Any rational analysis would show that closer ties between these two economies promise huge benefits for both sides. It is an economic alliance that the West justly fears. All sorts of pressure has been brought on our politicos to increase the alienation, and our brave leaders have succumbed. There is no logic, other than the immediate need in the depths of their pockets.

As Mahatma Gandhi knew, when there is no Swadesh there can be no Swaraj. Yet we no longer care for the Mahatma's advice.

Swadeshi is also prominently missing in agriculture. The obvious result is that while the prices of basic foods skyrocket, the traditional farmer gets poorer and poorer. Those that benefit directly, and immensely, are the stockists and 'middle men' - now a misnomer in itself for this niche has been fully occupied by MNC minions. It almost seems as though our political bosses are aching to replace the myriad millions of traditional farmers with mega farms controlled by a few choice corporate houses.

The new breed of MNC linked trading houses and cartels can stock (it used to be called 'hoard') and therefore exercise empty 'value addition' with impunity. They sell at self-created demand peaks in connivance with a government that will authorize exports of commodities that are in short supply. The obfuscation is most clearly visible when the government blames 'global' factors including that wonderful commodity, crude oil. The recent global spike up in the prices of commodities should actually have absolutely no impact on domestic prices when our own agricultural production is more than self sufficient! The same goes for cooking oil where retail prices at one stage rose by more than 50% over just a six month period!

Meanwhile, the farmers starve, fail to pay their debts, and commit suicide. We face a drought this year with the failure of the SW monsoons. And on the sidelines await the ever-eager property speculators, who are just waiting to pick up excellent farmland at distress sale prices, to hand over to the cash-rich agri-corps, who are also circling hungrily above. Once the carcass has been picked clean, we Indians who earn only a tenth of what the West averages, will yet pay the full 'global' price at par for our own commodities. Paying such a price to our existing farmers seems not to be an option. No, we will wait for the corporates to make the killing!

As Gandhiji remarked so many years ago, "Swadeshi is that spirit in us which requires us to serve our immediate neighbours before others, and to use things produced in our neighbourhood in preference to those more remote. So doing, we serve humanity to the best of our capacity. We cannot serve humanity by neglecting our neighbours"

And further and more pointedly, Swadeshi is "a call to the consumer to be aware of the violence he is causing by supporting those industries that result in poverty, harm to workers and to humans and other creatures"

The  maha atma Gandhi ji came, and did more than his bit to rescue us from our coils of slavery. There is no sense in yearning for him to come again. The only ones who can save us from our (oh so 'Gandhian') politicians, are ourselves. Right now we have only ourselves to blame for not calling our politicians to account. It is high time for our youth to rise and discover the true power of the ballot, voting for persons who have commitment to India, and are not so bent on first taking care of lining their own pockets. But that is only the beginning.

We must find ways to hold our politicos to account, to demand that they lead well and honestly, build institutions of democracy and justice, and demand that they have a vision for the India to build up a committed and caring India.

This post has been updated and redone to bring it up-to-date as of Feb 2015


Wednesday, September 28, 2011

Blood in Times of Scarcity

grey-platelets, top is a lymphocyte (white cell)
We have all known times when we, or some loved one, needed blood and we could not get it. The reasons may be numerous. Perhaps the blood needed is of a rare blood group, or perhaps there are no real blood 'banks' nearby! Often times in developing nations the supply mechanisms are just not in place or not functioning. Then there's the ubiquitous shortage of blood donors!

Blood bankers are the people on the spot when blood has been prescribed for a patient but apparently the blood is not available. What do you do?

Fortunately, nature itself has given us a few 'tricks' that can prove useful in times of crisis! The first and foremost trick is to use the component parts of blood to treat specific needs. As mentioned in my previous post, blood component use can expand the utility of a limited resource (blood and blood donors) to provide help to 3 or 4 times as many patients. Especially in times of scarcity that's a huge, huge advantage!

harvesting PRP
Nature's boon to us is that "blood" (meaning 'whole' blood), can easily be divided up into its parts, or components. A simple centrifuge spin will show two clear divisions, with straw yellow watery plasma on top (less dense) and the dark red cells below. Using multiple bags, the plasma can be removed into a satellite bag. If we have spun the blood gently, then within the plasma will be found the platelets. Platelets can then be concentrated with a slightly harder spin yielding platelet poor plasma (PPP) on top and the platelet concentrate at the bottom. So now we have three components of blood. Very rarely do people need more than one of these at a time. Voila, 1 blood donor can help to treat 3 patients!

The plasma (PPP) with its clotting factors can be fast frozen (now called  "Fresh Frozen Plasma" or FFP) and then stored at -40C for up to one year. All the clotting factors will work!

Sometimes, we will choose to remove some of the clotting factors (V and VIII with fibrinogen) from the plasma and use these separately for treating people like hemophilia sufferers. And there we have it, easily up to 4 different patients can be benefited from one blood donation!

Nature also lends us a helping hand for patients with rarer blood groups (e.g. often rh negative blood and AB group blood can be hard to find as occurring in only a small percentage of donors). The basic 4 blood groups (A, B, AB & O) were discovered more than a century ago. Rh factors were detected in the 1940s-1950s and were first found from studying problematic pregnancies. Thus, the rh 'problem' for rh negative women has become a matter of common knowledge. Now, a whole science of blood group serology has grown out of these humble beginnings!

When we make blood components we first separate the plasma from the red cells. Here lies nature's second BIG gift to us. Factors like rh and A and B that are the basis of the blood groups, are found ONLY on the red blood cells. These factors do not exist in the plasma. What is found in the plasma, are plasma proteins (immunoglobulins) that can potentially attack their opposite red cell factors. We are born with some of these proteins (anti A and anti B, but not rh). People with a blood group A, for example, will have the A factor on their red cells BUT their plasma will have anti B. It is a bit difficult to understand at first but the tables below summarize the antigen factors (red cell) and antibodies (plasma) for the ABO groups.

So, how does this help?
Well, supposing your patient needs AB group blood (red cells) and you cannot find a blood donor of AB group, it's actually generally just as safe safe to transfuse (crossmatch compatible) washed A group, B group or even O group RED CELLS alone to this patient!!!

Simply put, whatever is on the patient's red cells - the corresponding antibodies in the plasma must be avoided. An A group patient can receive O or A group red cells safely but NOT B or AB.

Again the table below will clarify the mixes and matches for red cells (packed red cells as they are often called) and for plasma.  The reverse case is therefore true for patients needing plasma! Consider the last column of the same table to decide on plasma compatibility: As you can see, an A group patient can receive A or AB plasma, NOT B or O.



Patient’s Blood Group
Compatible Components
Packed Red Cells, Platelet Concentrate
Plasma
A
A, O
A, AB
B
B, O
B, AB
AB
A, B, AB, O
Only AB
O
Only O
A, B, AB, O

Cell counters VERY important for PLT
For people needing whole blood, with a little immagination you can see that the combination of O group red cells and AB plasma are always acceptable (when the crossmatch is okay)! Other combinations will work too, e.g. an A group patient needing whole blood can have O or A red cells along with A or AB plasma.

A huge advantage of component separation is that when we fresh freeze plasma we can store large quantities of plasma to be used whenever needed! 'Packed' red cells can be safely stored for 35 to 42 days at +4C, and in fact with some extra technology (and cost) red cells can even be viably held at -80C (or in liquid nitrogen) for very long periods (up to 5 years).

The science of blood group serology has taught us that there are well over 300 different antigen factors found on red blood cells and (in other patients) corresponding antibodies found in plasma. Most of these are rare, but any active transfusion service will run into 1 or 2 a week. It is for these rarer cases that larger transfusion services will freeze and store away the rare donor red cells that come their way so that when a patient presents with a troublesome rare antibody, there is a better likelihood that compatible frozen red cells will save a life.  And that is another reason why crossmatch techniques have to be the best possible! You will not pick up any of these dangerous transfusions (or 'rare' donors) unless the crossmatching is always spot on! But we are now speaking of rarer difficulties (often 1:10,000 or rarer).

PLT concentrates in a horizontal shaker, temperature +22C
But, some more common problems that we face are also amenable to some 'trick' solutions! Take the case of a patient with low platelet counts who has started to bleed. The commonest causes might be a virus such as dengue, a drug (medication) reaction, or perhaps treatment for cancer. Whatever the case, platelets once needed are needed in some quantities, say 2-4 random donor platelet concentrates every 12 hours (the actual need will be decided by the physician and the clinical condition).

Finding donors can get especially difficult when the patient has a rarer blood group such as AB or rh negative. One unit of  Platelet Concentrate has about 50 to 70 mL of plasma but it also will contain a small amount of red cells, say 1 or 2 mL, and that's the reason for generally transfusing platelets according to 'red cell rules'. That small amount of red cells is enough to stimulate the production of antibodies like anti rh. Still, in a pinch, for MALE patients with life threatening bleeding, the physician may go ahead and transfuse blood group incompatible (but major crossmatch compatible) platelet concentrates.

Centrifuging blood in blood bags.
Where rh negative WOMEN patients are concerned, it gets complicated. Sometines women who have not had children have been found with rh antibody due to careless transfusions, pregnancies in the past, or other exposures to rh antigens. Still, a potential way out here is to use RhoGAM (which is nothing other than rh antibody) to bind the few problem-causing rh positive red cells found in platelet concentrates. In other words, we can do what we would do when an rh negative women is pregnant to prevent her own immune system from producing the rh antibody against the red cells from her fetus that may be crossing into her circulation!

Of course, the above are all purely medical decisions and only doctors can decide in each case what can and should be done. The blood banker's job is to make the solutions available to the physicians.

And as you can see, with sensible blood component technology backed with simple blood serology techniques, MUCH indeed can be done.  MOST IMPORTANTLY our blood needs can mainly be met using simple, ready to hand, inexpensive "third world ready" technologies.

The PRP on the left top has too many red cells (pink). QC is a must!
Blood bankers should always fine tune their crossmatch techniques to ensure that dangerous transfusions are avoided.

Building Confidence

Quality control is most critical in building physicians' confidence in your blood component program. The components, especially the very sensitive platelets, should have high enough counts in our PLT concentrates. We should aim to harvest 90% of the platelets from the donor blood into each concentrate and with the least contamination of red cells possible. The platelets should of course be viable, so gently spin out and gently agitate during storage while maintaining strict temperature control at +22C.

As the physicians' confidence grow, and as they see their difficult transfusion problems being solved with component technology and common sense, you will find that they will soon switch over to prescribing only blood components!

Manual Apheresis versus Automated Apheresis

Finally, a word on manual apheresis (much much less expensive) versus automated apheresis. I know that a significant amount of controversy was generated by my earlier post recommending manual apheresis in 3rd world countries, with some doubts even being expressed about the safety of the procedure. In India it is standard procedure at leading medical/hematology centers such as CMC Vellore. I refer the doubters to 2 out of many studies that have been published in leading transfusion medicine journals that prove that manual apheresis platelets are as safe (or safer) than those made with very fancy (& expensive!) automated equipment: See Vox Sang. 1989;57(1):25-8.In vitro and in vivo comparison of platelet concentrates collected by automated versus manual apheresis. Ross DG, Holme S, Heaton WA.Source American Red Cross Blood Services, Tidewater Region, Norfolk, Va.  &  Viability of platelets collected by apheresis versus the platelet-rich plasma technique: a direct comparison.by R A De Vries, M De Bruin, J J Marx, H C Hart, A Van De Wiel Transfusion Science (1993) Volume: 14, Issue: 4, Pages: 391-398  PubMed: 10146646 Available from www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

BLOOD COMPONENT SUMMARY:
RED CELLS (packed red cells PRBC) 180 mL to 200 mL, ~80% cells, <10% plasma, ~15% anticoagulant-additive (storage at +4C up to 42 days).
FRESH FROZEN PLASMA (FFP) 200 to 220 mL plasma, 30 mL anticoagulant, < <0 -40c="" .5="" 1="" at="" cells="" p="" red="" storage="" to="" up="" year="">PLATELET CONCENTRATE (PLT) 50 to 70 mL plasma, each 1 mL typically contains  120,000,000 platelets, and a minimum of 5.5 x 10 (10) in 50 to 70 mL of plasma with less than 1 mL red cells. (storage at +22C with gentle agitation for 5 days). For an average adult patient of 70 kg weight, the 'normal' blood volume would be 5 liters, and one unit of platelet concentrate should raise the count by ~ 10,000/microliter.


BLOOD COMPONENTS ARE A MATTER OF LIFE! 

NOTES:
1. Please do keep in mind that platelets once opened for transfusion cannot be stored. They should never be refrigerated even for short periods of time. Only +22C storage! If you use a part of a PLT concentrate, say for an infant, please discard the remainder and do not attempt to keep this for later use as the risk of bacterial contamination is extremely high! Once transfused, the platelets will usually take some time, a few hours, to equilibrate and start working to stop bleeding - an important point when preparing a patient for surgery!
2. A good antibody screen can be sometimes substituted for, or added to the crossmatch to make it even safer.
3. The standard amount of blood drawn for component preparation is usually 450 mL
4. I have not mentioned autologous blood transfusion here as this post is not really about blood for elective procedures, BUT the overall demand on donors for a transfusion center/blood bank will somewhat reduce if surgeons are also utilizing prior autologous transfusions.
5. A good read on the dengue epidemic in the Lahore area,  Dingi (Dengue) Fever in Lahore by Prof Farakh A. Khan It is very down to earth, see: http://networkedblogs.com/nE6gF
6. The Merck Manual has a useful summary of blood component use in clinical practice -  http://www.merckmanuals.com/professional/hematology_and_oncology/transfusion_medicine/blood_products.html
7. Be proactive and prepared! Find the phone numbers of the blood banks in your area (the ones that have stock of blood components) and store them up in your mobile for instant use. In an emergency, getting blood components fast can save lives.
8. Blood donors can encourage their blood banks to process blood into components. Ask your blood banker the next time you donate blood, whether they are routinely making blood components so that each time you donate, you will help to save 3 or even 4 lives.

Incidentally, I am a blood bank technical consultant and not a medical doctor. I will be happy to discuss the technical aspects of blood/blood components with anyone, but for medical advice please talk to your physician! You can mail me with any questions at samlcarr@gmail.com or call me, +91-8144068393

Sunday, September 18, 2011

Platelets in Developing Countries

Blood saves lives BUT wrong responses to blood needs are horribly wasteful, even criminally wasteful, and especially so in developing nations where the tech may not even work.

My present concern was ignited by a recent bit of news from Pakistan that the government was responding to the #DENGUE crisis (an epidemic affecting many thousands) in populous Lahore.  Like many viruses that cause bleeding, dengue can be most deadly in its hemorrhagic form, and the main cause of bleeding comes down to dropping platelet counts - and platelets are blood components that are the body's first line of defense against bleeds. The government proposes tossing out 40,000,000 (40 million!) rupees to purchase top-of-the-line blood cell separators as the cries for platelets from dengue sufferers have grown to a crescendo.

Sounds good, doesn't it! People desperately need platelets, so the government immediately jumps into action to meet that need... Well, unfortunately that's all it does is to 'sound' good!

And thats how complicated the 10k apheresis kit is!
In the first place, the machines themselves are very expensive. Perhaps the government will be able to buy a couple dozen machines for that money. But what's really very sad, such machines do not work at all on their own. You need to use 1 disposable kit for each donation. EACH platelet concentrate from one donor (single donor platelets or SDP) requires a (single use) kit and EACH kit costs anywhere from 10,000 to 20,000 Pak Rupees.

And that my friends, means that only the richest patients will be able to afford this treatment. In short, eventually, the government would have spent your public's tax money on a bunch of utterly useless machinery.

Being a blood banker, I also know that the time to implementation for blood cell separator tech is approximately a minimum of 3 months, so even supposing the government does something really brave, like subsidizing the cost of the kits, the whole setup will only go into action after the dengue is  long gone...
After 1 spin PRP above RBC

Of course, the spin-doctors might leave the public admiring the government's caring responsiveness, but ultimately the same thousands WILL DIE for lack of platelets.

Oh, I am not even going to harp much on the fact that properly using these machines requires a LOT of training, with a heck of a lot of infrastructure. These machines will not function safely on generators, and so will need large UPS backup. Then, doctors need to be trained in how to prescribe these SDP, which is a whole lot different from using the commonly available (random donor) platelet concentrate! And then there's the little practicalities like maintaining and servicing some very sophisticated machinery. In my experience, when asked to do after sales service, the sellers/manufacturers/agents found in 3rd world nations are so often adept at playing hard to get!

In other words, stuff like this is simply not appropriate for 3rd world economies. It is a simple thing to have blood cell separators (US 'apheresis' machines) as standard equipment for any US/European/Japanese blood transfusion service, but in those economies our 10,000 rupees is just $110, what an American might spend dining out just once, while to a Pakistani or an Indian that's one month's wages, and for just 1 day's treatment with SDP.

harvesting the platelet rich plasma
I also hardly need to remind folks that in all the 'fancy' countries there's insurance cover, or the governments there treat even their citizens' tertiary health problems with nationalized free treatment - and which developing nations can afford to do either of those things???

Now, I can't altogether blame the government for this fiasco. But then I can! It is typically the health ministry's responsibility to get proper advice from genuine experts and find workable and effective solutions to emergencies like the present dengue/platelet crisis. Solutions do so often exist; workable solutions, and much less expensive ones!

What would have been a more effective solution in Lahore? Encourage the existing network of blood banks in Pakistan to coordinate the supply of 'ordinary' platelet concentrates. Here, the technology is simple. Many blood banks will already have the centrifuges, and "triple bag" kits are readily available at very reasonable prices. It's also easy to train the technicians to make 'ordinary' platelet concentrate. Best of all, the end user cost is only a mere Rs 300/- to 500/- per platelet concentrate, of which a doctor may need to use just 1 or 2 every 12 hours to maintain the platelet count in a safe range, i.e. a cost to the patient of Rs 1,000 to 2,000 per day, (that's still expensive) to stay safely alive until the self-limiting dengue virus hopefully makes a quiet exit.

We, in third world countries, are often witness to much of such government over-enthusiasm. And it often enough isn't the result of stupidity, is it?  So very often we find that some extra-smart 'expert' government adviser somewhere has quietly pocketed a hefty commission (kickback/baksheesh) for suggesting a brilliant but useless scheme!

But, at what cost to the nation, and particularly at the cost of how many lives?


And so, to end the sermon, do try to work with locally effective technology rather than doing stuff that will only be a donation to some foreign manufacturer of completely useless-to-you white elephants. Think about it.

In the meantime, I would also urge all blood bankers to really, really, switch to blood components. Of course, you will not be able to do that unless physicians and surgeons start insisting on using only blood components! Coordinate - Educate!

So called 'whole' blood is a killer when used to treat drops in platelet counts. Whole blood can dangerously load the circulation as you are putting in an extra 350 mL of blood (and completely unneeded red cells lead to hemoconcentration) to get an effect equal to the platelets found in just 50 to 70 mL of platelet concentrate.
I've personally witnessed volume overloads  and very high hematocrits resulting from such whole blood mistransfusions that literally killed patients!

I would simultaneously urge all blood donors to request their blood banks to collect blood in multiple bags so that blood component processing becomes simple and safe. If you see just a single bag without 'satellite bags' attached, go ahead and donate, but then go and meet the blood bank director and tell that person that you will feel much more motivated to be a regular donor if they quickly move to blood components - BECAUSE, your one blood donation (made into components) can serve 3 to 4 patients, and is in any case always safer and more effective than 'whole' blood!

Wouldn't you want to save many precious lives each time you donate your precious blood? I certainly do...

P.S. Blood Components : From 1 unit (450 mL) of 'whole' blood = Red Cells (180 mL) + Fresh Frozen Plasma (200 mL) + Platelet Concentrate (max 70 mL). Sometimes the plasma can further be split to provide clotting factor VIII concentrate and plain plasma (without this clotting factor). So, 1 blood donation made into it's components can help save at least 3 lives or even more!


PLATELET STORAGE & TRANSPORT
The platelets in 'whole' blood get killed when the blood temperature drops below +20 C. Whole blood is typically stored at +4 C. So unless the 'whole' blood is fresh and uncooled, it's totally useless for platelets anyway! However, once platelet concentrate is made from fresh warm blood, it is good for at least 5 days at +22 C, so can also be transported to from central processing units to wherever the demand exists. Platelets need to be maintained at this temperature of +22 C and be gently agitated.

PLATELET DONORS:
Should have a healthy platelet count. Should not have any bleeding disorder. Should not have smoked, taken aspirin or Aggrenox for at least 48 hours, or any antiplatelet meds like Plavix (clopidogrel) for 10 days before donation and of course should meet the other general requirements for blood donation (minimum height-weight etc.).

* Pics on the left show parts of the 'low' tech processing of blood manually to get the blood components safely out and this is all done within a closed sterile blood bag system. The triple bag is most commonly used to provide the 3 main blood components.

SHARE THIS NOW

Google+ javascript:(function(){var now=new Date(),month=now.getMonth()+1;day=now.getDate();year=now.getFullYear();window.polarbear=window.polarbear||{};var D=550,A=450,C=screen.height,B=screen.width,H=Math.round((B/2)-(D/2)),G=0,F=document,E;if(C>A){G=Math.round((C/2)-(A/2))}window.polarbear.shareWin=window.open('https://www.polarbearapp.com/app','','left='+H+',top='+G+',width='+D+',height='+A+',personalbar=0,toolbar=0,scrollbars=1,resizable=1');E=F.createElement('script');E.src='//www.polarbearapp.com/js/web-bookmarklet.js?v='+month+'-'+day+'-'+year;F.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(E)}());